Tue, 04 Jan 2005

The Blue Gold Rush

Remember when my bike was stolen two months ago? I was pretty pissed off, and I still remember. :)

The first thing I had to do was buy a 10 trip ticket for València's Metro system. These tickets are quite expensive, more than in Madrid or Barcelona, but fortunately I normally can go everywhere cycling and don't use the Metro much. Actually, when the bike was stolen, it had been months since the last time I took it, but I relied on its unreliable system for a week or two while I got a new bike to get going again.

The first days were a bit painful, because there's not that many trains as in other cities, so it might take either 15 minutes or 45 to do the same distance, depending on your luck with connections and timetables.

After the first week, something changed in my perception of the service. Once I had used my first five trips, I went into a Metro station and inserted the ticket. When it came out, I noticed it had marked over the fifth slot again. That happened a few more times; then the cancelling machines started printing lines somewhere not on the ticket, and finally I got my gift, when on another trip the cancelling machine said I had 128 trips left. Woot! That means free rides for a looong time. The 128 figure is suspicious. Once, I saw one of these machines open, and it was running MS-DOS, so who knows what kind of overflow my card might have caused...

I could take advantage of this when mako came visit València and we shared the ticket for a week. We started calling it the "BLUE GOLD", and people would look at us oddly inside the train when he said "YOU'VE GOT BLUE GOLD, MAN!". The effects have gotten better lately: it now never marks anything and when I use it to open the gates to get out of the Metro stations, sometimes the machines go bonkers and leave the doors open, while their display reads Error, allowing people that haven't paid for a ticket an easy escape from the station. :)

The bad news is that this will end on January 31, as the fees have changed and the old tickets will be obsoleted starting on February. I wonder if I can easily find someone that uses the Metro more than twice a day and sparing the money would help his economy a lot. Or I could try to be selfish and sell it. 51¢ x ∞ sounds like a good deal.

While this happened, I didn't manage to fix up my new bicycle, and I managed to go through the worst part of winter underground. Hopefully I'll start riding it again next week, as this has been the longest period of time with me not riding bicycles at all in the last 9 years and you end up missing it.

People were looking at us strangely before we started talking about blue good.

Posted by mako at Tue Jan 4 19:22:34 2005

Haha, yes.
Having you in front of me doing the "I'm getting angry" funny look probably made it quite easy for others to wonder "WTF IS GOING ON"...

Posted by jordi at Tue Jan 4 19:45:24 2005

You are bragging about committing fraud against the metro line?  Perhaps you should think hard about what it felt like to have your bike stolen because now you are doing the same.

Posted by Bob at Tue Jan 4 20:07:15 2005

lol, definitely NOT the same. I have paid for a ticket, and their fucking stupid retarded system is so broken it's letting me in, for now. I bought a ticket in the first place.

Besides, this company has abused with the fares for about 15 years, and I've put lots of money into their abusive, monopolistic business.

I have dealt with bad timetables, very late, or sometimes, cancelled trains, etc, etc.

My bicycle, on the other hand, was mine. I had paid for it. It was old (15 years, as well) and had no value at all: it weighed a ton, was rusty and the gears were quite fucked up. But it was my old bike and I loved it. More importantly, I needed it daily.

The extra free rides I'm getting in the Metro these days are one of the fields in their budget for 2004.

Posted by Jordi at Tue Jan 4 20:26:05 2005

I'm not laughing ("lol," as you say).  You are stealing.  You seem to be pretty good at rationalizing it to yourself, though.

Posted by Bob at Tue Jan 4 20:56:17 2005

bob, realise that some people (like me) consider the obligation to pay for public transportation as theft.  I think that the metro should be free, for several reasons.  Amongst them, to ease freeing the cities of cars, and not to charge the poorest classes who use the metro more than anybody else.  I systematically jump the fences and feel no guilt at all.

Posted by enric at Wed Jan 5 21:01:54 2005

Hey, thanks Enric. :)

I feel exactly the same. Not even the students have discounts, even after the major has promised free rides for them. The only people that have some discounts are the elder.

Public transport is a public service, normally run by public companies, or private companies funded with public money. It would be perfectly ok to make the fares symbolic so that it would not be a real expense for those that really need the money for other things.

I don't drive a car, but I pay for the maintenance of street pavements, paint, signs and traffic lights. We users of bicycles and metro should be supported by the rest of the tax payers, as we do. Sure, there's a "circulation tax", but there's lots of things that I pay for drivers that aren't covered by that tax.

Enric is very correct when he says that with a free service, or at least at a reasonable price, a lot more people would use the metro and busses, making cities less of a shitty place to live in, and a less polluted place, too.

Posted by Jordi at Wed Jan 5 21:36:51 2005

There's a difference between stealing and being too-honest.  You bought a ticket in good faith.  If your ticket didn't work you'd buy another one.  To refuse to use your blue-gold would be stupid.  Particularly as the problem is their fault.

Fate/God/Random acts of the universe have given you an opportunity.  Take it an evolve :)

Posted by Aidan Delaney at Tue Feb 8 15:27:19 2005

Funny how people seem to forget that maintaining a public transport system costs nothing and that using it has no cost.  Think that when you are using the metro, you occupy a seat, someone needs to clean up mess from travelers, etc..

I don't see why public transport should be free and why people not using it should pay with their taxes for people using it.

I'm using the metro daily and I'm perfectly happy to pay for it instead of having a car.

enric: believe it or not, you actually USE traffic lights, signs and pavement everytime you cross the street, take a bus, ride a bicycle ... or rent a car next time you move to another house.

Posted by benj at Tue Feb 8 15:28:07 2005

Of course public transport is not free. But what is the diffrence between the seats in the park and the seats on the train? Why cleanning the streets should be "free" but cleaning the metro station shouldn't?

That's what taxes are for. Making the metro free would reduce the private car usage, and will save more in road and parking costs than lost on the income from the metro tickets.

Posted by Yuri at Tue Feb 8 16:40:28 2005

Funny how people seem to forget that maintaining a public highway costs nothing and that using it has no cost. Think that when you are using a road, you occupy space, someone needs to clean up the muck that falls off your car, etc..

I don't see why public highways should be free and why people not using it should pay with their taxes for people using it.

I'm using the highways daily and I'm perfectly happy to pay for it instead of using public transport.

OK, so the above's a bit extreme, but the point is reasonable; maintaining roads in a good enough condition for cars to use them costs more than is claimed from car drivers in taxation. Surely public transport should be subsidised to the same extent, especially if you want to encourage people out of their cars?

Posted by Farnz at Tue Feb 8 18:28:07 2005

(Hi Farnz)

jordi, how would you feel if someone abused a server you were running, and their defence was "your stupid software shouldn't have let me in"?

Posted by Jon at Tue Feb 8 22:12:58 2005

Hey Jon.  I've used that argument before. =)

Posted by jb at Wed Feb 9 22:50:17 2005

Jordi, no le hagas caso a estos. Simplemente están celosos de no tener la puta tarjeta. Lo único que me preocupa es que algún alcahuete de aquí le avise a alguien de metrovalencia, así que cuidado. Saludos.

Posted by dario at Thu Feb 10 00:25:39 2005

Wicked!!!!

As far as copying it goes...

Have you got a tape recorder? You should be able to line it up to record the data as a signal onto a normal audio cassette, however this is silly... BECAUSE WE LIVE IN THE DIGITAL AGE!

So, tare apart a tape recorder, hook up a simple low power amp and input it into your sound card (simplest analogue input i think you'll agree), then recording the signal, you should then work toward cleaning it up and verifying it.

The only problem is that I can't see a way of doing this without mangling the original card.

If you do manage to digitize it, open source it!

FULL DISCLOSURE OF METRO BUGS!

Posted by Karl Lattimer at Mon Nov 21 12:05:35 2005